Rangers manager Ron Washington came out to argue, but the umpiring crew chose not to utilize the instant-replay system that is allowed by Major League Baseball on boundary home run calls.
"His opinion was that the ball left the field, and the fans didn't come on the field to impede with his opportunity to catch it," Washington said during his in-game interview with TBS.
Cruz respectfully disagreed.
"I thought the fan touched and grabbed my glove. I thought it was fan interference," he said.
Washington, according to Reynolds, did not directly ask for the umpires to review the replay.
"No," said Reynolds. "He asked me the same question you asked me, 'What did you have.' I said, 'Ron, the ball was in the stands.'"
Crew chief Gerry Davis, who saw the replay after the game, supported the decision made by Reynolds.
"The ball was in the stands," Davis said.
According to Rule 3.16 in the MLB rulebook, "When there is spectator interference with any thrown or batted ball, the ball shall be dead at the moment of interference and the umpire shall impose such penalties as in his opinion will nullify the act of interference. If spectator interference clearly prevents a fielder from catching a fly ball, the umpire shall declare the batter out."
And the rule also states at Part D: "Spectator interference occurs when a spectator reaches out of the stands, or goes on the playing field, and touches a live ball. On any interference, the ball is dead."
The fans involved -- brothers Jared Macchirole, 20, and Jay Macchirole, 27, of Queens -- got caught up in the moment.
"It's a reaction. You see the ball coming at you, you try to catch it, and that's what happened," said Jay Macchirole. "It was a home run ball regardless. We caught it over the wall. Once it's over the wall in home run territory, it's anybody's ball. And we went after it, and we got it. It was above the cement. We reached over, it hit me, [Jared] grabbed it, Nelson Cruz started [complaining and] started pointing at us."
Jared Macchirole sure appeared to get a good grip on Cruz's glove.
"I did not touch the glove," Jared Macchirole said. "I certainly know he pointed at me and my brother afterwards, [but] I certainly wasn't trying to interfere."
The play recalled memories of Game 1 in the 1996 ALCS, when a fan named Jeffrey Maier, 12 years old at the time, reached over the right-field wall at the old Yankee Stadium to pull in a Derek Jeter home run. The homer tied the game, and the Yankees went on to win. In that case, Orioles right fielder Tony Tarasco looked like he was going to catch the ball had Maier not interfered. But the call stood.
Maier was watching Game 4 from a television at LaGuardia Airport on Tuesday night.
"I thought they put those bars up there to prevent that from happening? I guess not. Those guys had pretty good access," Maier said in an interview with Newsday.
Two batters later, Berkman hit a towering shot down the line in right field. Reynolds signaled home run, and Berkman trotted around the bases amid the roar of the Yankee Stadium crowd.
Washington again came out, and this time, he asked the umpires to take another look. His wish was granted.
"In that situation, I wasn't confident of what I had, and we got together and we went to the replay," Reynolds said.
After the umpires huddled in front of the replay camera on the third-base side, it was ruled a foul ball. According to a multitude of replays shown on TBS, the drive appeared to be foul by inches, as it stayed on the right side of the foul pole.
"I thought it was fair, really, to be honest with you," said Berkman. "Maybe not quite as clearly, but I looked at that replay 50 times and was like, 'Did that thing graze the foul pole?' It's close."
Berkman wound up striking out. So instead of a 2-0 lead, the Yankees were up by just one.
Texas rallied right back with two runs in the top of the third to take a brief lead before New York went back on top.
But the Rangers would later take control of the game and are just one win away from going to their first World Series.